Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Marketing Agency

Before hiring a marketing agency, ask questions that reveal five things: how they build strategy, what results they've delivered, who will actually do the work, how they report and communicate, and what the contract commits you to. The best agencies answer with specifics, numbers, and examples. Weak ones answer with buzzwords and promises.

The reality is most small businesses hire an agency based on a good sales call and a nice portfolio. Then they spend six months figuring out what they actually bought. The right questions up front save you the money and the months.

Quick answer: the 5 most important questions to ask a marketing agency

1. How will you measure success, and how does it connect to my revenue?
2. Can you show results for a business similar to mine?
3. Who exactly will work on my account, and what's their experience?
4. What happens in the first 90 days?
5. What are the contract terms, and what happens if I want to leave?

Before you ask: get clear on three things

The best questions come from knowing what you need. Spend 15 minutes on these before your first agency call:

• Your goal. More leads, more bookings, a new location, a slow season to fill? Pick one or two, with a number if you can.
• Your budget. Know your monthly range for agency fees and, separately, for ad spend. Agencies can't propose the right plan without it.
• Your current numbers. How many leads you get a month, where they come from, and roughly what a customer is worth. Even rough answers help.

Most teams miss this: if you can't explain what success looks like, no agency can deliver it. The agency that asks you these questions before pitching is already showing you how it thinks.

20 questions to ask a marketing agency

Strategy: do they think before they execute?

1. What would you need to know about my business before recommending anything? A good agency asks about your customers, margins, and goals before pitching services.
2. Who do you think my target customer is, and how would you reach them? Listen for specifics, not "we'll target everyone in your area."
3. Which channels would you skip for my business, and why? An agency that recommends everything is selling hours, not strategy.
4. How do the services you offer work together? SEO, social, ads, and your website should feed one system, not run as separate projects.

Results: can they prove it?

5. Can you show results for a business like mine? Same industry, size, or local market. Ask for numbers, not just screenshots of pretty posts.
6. What metrics will you report on? Look for leads, calls, bookings, and revenue, not only followers and impressions.
7. What results should I expect at 30, 90, and 180 days? Honest agencies give ranges and explain what drives them.
8. Can I talk to a current client? A confident agency will connect you.

Team: who actually does the work?

9. Who will work on my account day to day? Get names and roles, not just the person on the sales call.
10. Is any of the work outsourced or white-labeled? It's not always bad, but you should know.
11. How many clients does my account manager handle? Too many means slow replies and generic work.
12. Do you have experience with my audience? For example, bilingual audiences, local markets, or your specific industry.

Process: how will working together feel?

13. What happens in the first 90 days? You should hear a clear onboarding plan with milestones.
14. How often will we meet, and how do I reach you? Agree on response times up front.
15. What do you need from me? Approvals, photos, access, and time. Know the commitment.
16. How do you handle it when something isn't working? The answer reveals whether they adjust or make excuses.

Money and contracts: what are you committing to?

17. What exactly is included in the monthly fee? Get deliverables in writing.
18. Is ad spend included or separate? Many agencies charge management fees on top of ad budgets.
19. How long is the contract, and how do I cancel? Know the minimum term and notice period.
20. Who owns my accounts, content, and data? You should own your ad accounts, website, social profiles, and analytics, even if you leave.

Good answers vs. red-flag answers

The question matters less than how they answer it. Here's what to listen for.

One red flag isn't always a dealbreaker. Two or more on the same call usually is.

How to compare agencies side by side

After two or three calls, the conversations blur together. Score each agency from 1 to 5 right after the call, while it's fresh.

The highest total wins, with one exception: if an agency scores a 1 or 2 on Proof or Terms, think hard before signing, no matter how good the rest looks.

The metric anchor: whichever agency you choose, agree in writing on the two or three numbers you'll judge them on at day 90. That one step heads off the most common agency disappointment: never agreeing on what success meant.

Frequently asked questions

What should I ask a marketing agency before hiring them?

Ask how they build strategy, what results they've delivered for similar businesses, who will do the work, how they report and communicate, and what the contract includes. Ask how they measure success and who owns your accounts and data.

What are red flags when hiring a marketing agency?

Common red flags include guaranteed rankings or viral results, reporting only likes and followers, vague answers about who does the work, long contracts with unclear deliverables, and agencies that own your ad accounts or website.

How long should a marketing agency contract be?

Many agencies ask for an initial commitment of about three months, since most marketing needs time to show results, then move to month to month. Be cautious with long lock-ins that have no clear exit terms.

Should I own my ad accounts and website if I hire an agency?

Yes. You should own your ad accounts, website, domain, social profiles, and analytics, and give the agency access. That way you keep your data and history if you change agencies.

How do I know if a marketing agency is right for a small business?

Look for an agency that asks about your goals first, shows results for businesses your size, explains a clear 90-day plan, and reports on leads and revenue, not just engagement.

Is ad spend included in a marketing agency's fee?

Usually not. Most agencies charge a management fee, and you pay the ad platforms separately. Confirm this in writing before you sign.

The bottom line

A marketing agency should be able to answer every question on this list with specifics. If they can't explain how they'll measure success, who's doing the work, and what you own when you leave, keep looking.

The right agency won't just sell you services. It will show you the system it's building and the numbers it will be accountable for.

Ask us all 20. JG Collective is a bilingual marketing agency for Utah small businesses. You own every account, every report ties back to leads and revenue, and our 90-day plan is laid out before you sign. Book a free consultation and bring this list.

‍